New Pride & Prejudice Show Gets Better RT Reviews Than Keira Knightley Version

A fresh take on a beloved literary world is winning over critics and audiences alike. A new Pride & Prejudice-inspired series is quietly building strong buzz, even outperforming the 2005 film starring Keira Knightley in early ratings. The spotlight this time shifts to a lesser-known Bennet sister, offering a different lens on a familiar story.

What critics are saying about The Other Bennet Sister in reviews?

The Other Bennet Sister is getting praise for its new perspective and grounded storytelling. Critics say the show breathes fresh life into Pride and Prejudice by focusing on Mary Bennet, often overlooked in earlier adaptations. Meghan O’Keefe from Decider noted that its “fresh approach… enhances Austen’s enduring genius” while giving viewers a new heroine to connect with.

Performances have also stood out, especially from Ella Bruccoleri. Peter Martin from ScreenAnarchy described her work as “exquisite,” adding that the show balances warmth with subtle emotional depth. Other critics highlighted its comforting tone, with ScreenRant calling it a “cozy, uplifting” extension of Austen’s world rather than a direct retelling.

Some reviews point out its softer approach compared to flashier period dramas. James Croot from The Post said it may not match the scale of Bridgerton, but it still delivers for fans craving “Regency-era” storytelling. Meanwhile, Ed Power described it as a tribute to outsiders, giving emotional weight to characters who don’t usually take center stage.

The Other Bennet Sister gets better Rotten Tomatoes score than 2005’s Pride & Prejudice

The numbers back up the positive buzz. The show currently holds a 94% critics’ score and a matching 94% audience rating on Rotten Tomatoes, putting it ahead of the 2005 film adaptation in early comparisons. That’s a strong sign that this quieter, character-driven story is resonating widely.

Alongside Bruccoleri, the cast includes Ruth Jones, Indira Verma, Laurie Davidson, and Richard Coyle. Together, they help shape a version of Austen’s world that feels both familiar and refreshingly different.

Source: Comingsoon.net